Just Because It's Trending Doesn't Mean It's True
Hoax Alert

Fake News: Democrats Did NOT Gain A Seat In Congress For Every 770,000 Illegals Who Filled Out The 2010 U.S. Census In A Sanctuary City Or State

  • by: Alan Duke
  • (Wed, 18 Sep 2019 21:16:37 Z)

Did Democrats gain a congressional seat for every 770,000 illegal immigrants counted in a sanctuary city or state by the 2010 U.S. census? No, that's not true: It is a claim based on bad math, ignoring election history, demographic trends showing a declining number of undocumented immigrants, and many factors that determine how congressional seats are apportioned and districts drawn. Our analysis of the 2010 census, the resulting congressional reapportionment, the 2012 election results, and the list of "sanctuary" governments concluded that the claim is unsupported by the facts.

The meme was introduced with the claim that "Illegal immigrants have become the MOST POWERFUL WEAPON in the Democratic Party's arsenal!" Given the trend toward fewer undocumented residents counted in each annual survey over the past decade, the opposite could be true.

Lead Stories found the claims in a post (archived here) published on the Conservative Reiding Facebook group on March 29, 2018. It read:

FOR EVERY 770,000 ILLEGALS WHO FILLED OUT THE 2010 U.S. CENSUS IN A SANCTUARY CITY OR STATE, THE DEMOCRATS GOT ANOTHER SEAT N THE US HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES APPORTIONED TO THEM!

Screenshot of https://www.facebook.com/ConservativeReiding/photos/a.1440085059363905/1792520100787064/?type=3&__xts__%5B0%5D=68.ARCoUA_cS6dkfMchHqlkcNtZ3W4keXnIfCCXDTZ7YfshGYuqQhzeM36u78CLJ2nrme4o2VBUNT4o7Vz4k8LKFnp5CQdvMwmAG7h4hRyLBteold7Y_C0f4HRwuEP1eLBgdaBXg6Ns8i-kRneHn8GFQteXF36Ooi7twshcNyaKZ7_hyN1gLZ5sHhfREJZwGyun99NZZR_3-Qy8rW_pqFjJlVNW2I5kGe4jsuE2L_5raSiflJ90mTvnujCIXfP1HA17KHdcbnjExAy2xyw9I_3Eb5GuFgFgxTwfAB31vvDE4IKBIbSjEeY6YpeT21sAoFJLeuDgkM-f&__tn__=-R

This is what socia media users saw:

The full message that introduced the meme read:

After every ten year US Census, the 435 seats in the US House of Representatives gets divided up based on population numbers. Based on the 2010 Census, a member of Congress represented 770,000... Soooo, if you had a Sanctuary City where 770,000 Illegal Aliens filled out the US Census, then that Sanctuary City was given a Seat in the US Congress and since ALL SANCTUARY CITIES ARE DEMOCRAT-CONTROLLED, EVERY TIME 770,000 ILLEGALS FILL OUT THE CENSUS, THE DEMOCRATS GET ANOTHER SEAT IN CONGRESS!

When we talk about Illegal Aliens impacting elections, typically folks think about voter fraud, which is a serious issue. BUT, what most miss is that concentrations of illegals filling out the US Census guarantees seats in the US Congress for the Democrats...

Illegal immigrants have become the MOST POWERFUL WEAPON in the Democratic Party's arsenal!

The publisher uses the last U.S. census as a predictor of what could happen in 2020, with the premise being that Democrats turned cities and states under their control into "sanctuaries" for undocumented residents so they could pad their population ahead of the next census. Since the 435 seats in congress are apportioned based on the census numbers, it would mean additional seats for Democrats, the logic goes. But that is not what happened in 2010 and is unlikely to happen in 2020. First, what is a "sanctuary" government? Here is the definition provided by the Center for Immigration Studies, a non-partisan think that promotes a "vision which seeks fewer immigrants but a warmer welcome for those admitted."

These cities, counties, and states have laws, ordinances, regulations, resolutions, policies, or other practices that obstruct immigration enforcement and shield criminals from ICE -- either by refusing to or prohibiting agencies from complying with ICE detainers, imposing unreasonable conditions on detainer acceptance, denying ICE access to interview incarcerated aliens, or otherwise impeding communication or information exchanges between their personnel and federal immigration officers.

The CIS told Lead Stories they did not have a list of "sanctuary" governments for 2010, so we will use the group's 2019 list, which is likely much longer since many cities were added to in recent years.

Eight states gained congressional seats due to the 2010 population count: Arizona, Florida (+2), Georgia, Nevada, South Carolina, Texas(+4), Utah and Washington.
None of these states are considered (or ever have been) "sanctuary states," although Washington is home to "sanctuary city" Seattle. Three of these states added Republican members and five added Democrats. Only one of the new Democrats came from a "sanctuary city" -- Seattle.

Ten states lost congressional seats after the 2010 census: Illinois, Iowa, Louisiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, Missouri, New Jersey, New York (-2), Ohio (-2) and Pennsylvania.

Seven of these 10 losers are either "sanctuary" states or have major counties that are. These results do not support the theory that being a "sanctuary" is a great strategy for growing congressional numbers.

It is a fact that most illegal immigrants reside in metropolitan areas, but not necessarily "sanctuaries." The Pew Research Center estimates that about 60 percent are concentrated in 20 metro areas. Only about half of these top 20 cities for illegal immigrants are on the "sanctuaries" list:

Illegal immigrants are counted for apportioning congressional districts, but they cannot vote. The false meme assumes that their presence in a district is a boost for Democratic candidates, but they are not a factor in which party wins the district. The meme also ignores how state legislatures can draw district lines to minimize or increase the impact of support from a demographic group. But the biggest factor that is overlooked is the consistent decrease in the illegal immigrant population around the United States.

FT_19.06.12_5FactsIllegalImmigration_US-unauthorized-immigrant-total.png

If "sanctuaries" such as a Los Angeles are counting on illegal immigrants to gain congressional seats, the have a flawed strategy since the numbers are falling. California lost an estimated 775,000 illegal immigrant residents in the decade from 2007 to 2017, accoring to Pew.

FT_19.06.12_UnauthorizedImmigration_Unauthorized-immigrant-populations-states-2.png

Want to inform others about the accuracy of this story?


Click this link to copy it to your clipboard
Then click here if you have Facebook or click here if you have Twitter to see who is sharing it (it might even be your friends...) and leave the link in the comments.

About the author:

Editor-in-Chief Alan Duke co-founded Lead Stories after ending a 26-year career with CNN, where he mainly covered entertainment, current affairs and politics. Duke closely covered domestic terrorism cases for CNN, including the Oklahoma City federal building bombing, the UNABOMBER and search for Southeast bomber Eric Robert Rudolph. CNN moved Duke to Los Angeles in 2009 to cover the entertainment beat. Duke also co-hosted a daily podcast with former HLN host Nancy Grace, "Crime Stories with Nancy Grace" and hosted the podcast series "Stan Lee's World: His Real Life Battle with Heroes & Villains." You'll also see Duke in many news documentaries, including on the Reelz channel, CNN and HLN.

Read more about or contact Alan Duke

About Lead Stories

Lead Stories uses the Trendolizer™ engine to detect the most trending stories from known fake news, satire and prank websites and tries to debunk them as fast as possible. Read more about how we work and how we select stories to check here.

Spotted a hoax that you think we should investigate? Have a tip? Want to send us a correction? Contact us!

You can also follow us here:

Most read

Recent

Like or Follow us to get the latest!

NEW! Subscribe to our YouTube channel: